I was a Smiths / Cure t-shirt wearing, alterna/punk/gothi/shoegazer -freak through-out high school, college and post college... Not only did I often not 'appear' in photos... I didn't dress any different at halloween...
I'd more than likely, still dress that way if the wife and daughter would let me still live in my house... though, probably a Strung Out, or Dashboard t-shirt now.
I'll have to see if I can dig up some picture for ya