oldirti

Basically I'm putting this up to rate different dedicated squads
If your squad wants to be put up for rating, pm me. You can have up to 3 of your dedicated squads per squad leader. there will be 3 phases to this.

-Phase one/week one: SL's PM me w/ squad names and brief descriptions, I will update them all after the week is over.
-Phase two/week two: People post on this thread rating any squad(s) they want on a 1-5 star ranking. If high ranking, give reason. If low ranking, give reason also.
-Phase three: I will make a new thread averaging each Squads ranking.

Hopefully we can get an accurate ranking of the dedicated squads here.

__________________

Grunt 70

Squad members and squad leaders change so frequently, even in the course of one game I'm having trouble understanding what value this process will hold beyond ranking a specific squad's action on a specific day. Next time the squad leader forms up it could be with a completely different line up or completely different mission...Am I missing something?

__________________
|TG-22nd|Grunt



"When force is necessary, it must be applied boldly, decisively, and completely. But one must know the limitations of force; one must know when to blend force with maneuver" - Leon Trotsky

oldirti

It's not for people who make an occasional squad, it for SL's who make squads every game with the same name usually.

IE: my squad, Dirti Tact, INF only i like to think it's a bit known

or dirtboy's squad which is well known TG Assualt.

__________________

Delta*RandyShugart*

edited.

__________________
|TG-6th|RandyShugart


"Follow my tracers!"

"If your posts made a sound then you might be in the running for the most annoying sound in the world." - from my favorite admirer Switch. We have a Ike Turner/Tina Turner Relationship, me being Ike Turner of course.

Ask not what TG can do you for you, but what can do for TG.
9/11 - Never Forget

oldirti

I seriously hope me not being a supporting member makes you think me a bad person? I simply don't have the funds to get it.

This isn't supposed to put anyone down. If you don't think your squad is run up to par, you don't have to participate. Infact there might not be any participants, but it was just an endeavor.

__________________

Elwenil

I wouldn't be seriously worried about putting anyone down, but I would be concerned that it could make certain squads seem "exclusive" and could lead to some grumbling.

__________________
|TG|Elwenil

oldirti

Most of the good SL's leave their Squads in a first come first serve, though some do keep it closed, That's fine too.

__________________

Delta*RandyShugart*

not at all, i didn't mean to come off that way.

__________________
|TG-6th|RandyShugart


"Follow my tracers!"

"If your posts made a sound then you might be in the running for the most annoying sound in the world." - from my favorite admirer Switch. We have a Ike Turner/Tina Turner Relationship, me being Ike Turner of course.

Ask not what TG can do you for you, but what can do for TG.
9/11 - Never Forget

d1sp0sabl3H3r0

Uh, WTF does that have to do with anything? I'm sure you're just joking around, but seriously, why even throw something like that out there?


I have no problem with this thread. If memory serves correct (which is a rarity lately), Dirti started a similar thread a couple of months ago about dedicated squads. I see this thread as an extension of that thread. Of course, popularity of a dedicated squad can be judged proportional to the time in which it fills up once created methinks.

__________________
|TG-X|d1sp0sabl3

Delta*RandyShugart*

dirti is one of the most respected sl's around, i've learned a lot from him, and from his teachings i've been able to setup ambushes and keep my patience when waiting for the right moment to storm a building or to fire onto an oncoming vechile/blow c4.

i will edit my opening thread, it was merely in a joking manner. I have nothing against voting for great sl's and squad members, but i also thought thats what AAR's are about and what the ribbons are also for. This could be a good addition to the the AAR thread that is listed within tactical gamer.

__________________
|TG-6th|RandyShugart


"Follow my tracers!"

"If your posts made a sound then you might be in the running for the most annoying sound in the world." - from my favorite admirer Switch. We have a Ike Turner/Tina Turner Relationship, me being Ike Turner of course.

Ask not what TG can do you for you, but what can do for TG.
9/11 - Never Forget

oldirti

Yes disposable i did (your memory's alright) I was thinking about making a Ver.3 but, wanted to try something else. I think this thread is getting more controversy than it's worth, but i still hope it picks up.

__________________

ollie_fool

Well i think its a good idea at least.

My squads are generally called;
> 2NOOBY - Inf sqd
> TOWNOOBY - Tow humvee sqd
> TANKNOOBY - Armour
Im generally nooby, some frequent sqd members include
>NOT NATO_ecko
>Nerdydodge
>Vlexo.com
>Corporal_cody
And some others who i dont remember so much

Also Gabbane

TheSkudDestroyer

I just... feel like this is begging for flame wars or community bickering...

__________________
|TG-6th|Skud, NA Deputy Lead Tester

† Disciple †

Bridge STU:
Well I personaly liked Skuds 'Bridge STU' (not sure if it was STU but it had three letters in it). I've been in it a couple of times and was great fun, I also like the fact he was open to others ideas, so the experiene was not all about one man and his orders. Not sure if he makes it outside of Fools Road though hehe.

Al's Squad:
Dunno if Bg Gay Al acturly names his squadsbut I like being in them specificaly because he will designate people there roles in the squad. The worst thing I think a Squad leader can do if say "grab what your good at" or "we need a medic and an AT so make sure to have them". I like to know whos got what and what they will be spawning with every time, makes much more easy and structured teamwork.

__________________

TheSkudDestroyer

Bridge SFU is attempted blowing of the bridge on Fools, over and over.

__________________
|TG-6th|Skud, NA Deputy Lead Tester