No announcement yet.

Not as Smart as We Think We Are


  • Not as Smart as We Think We Are

    Marshall McLuhan, a Canadian media scholar, put media studies in the daily news and at the forefront of the social sciences in the last century when he drew a convincing connection between content, medium, brain, and society. McLuhan's insights were correct, although his theories about the nature of the connection were often fanciful and quickly disproven.

    Over sixty years after McLuhan's initial connection between mind and medium we are still trying to assess the nature of media's effects upon us. A team of researchers at the University of Rochester just published a study about the impact of gaming upon an aspect of decision making known as "probabilistic inference", and for the Tactical Gaming community, the news appears to be all good.

    Yet when it comes to our media habits, effects are seldom indisputable and they are usually contradictory. Media use gives and takes away. So we need to be a cautious before we jump to the conclusion that gaming has positive real-world consequences.

    You have probably already heard about the latest research published in Current Biology. It was covered by The Economist and most English-speaking newspapers around the world. The researchers' conclusion is unequivocal:
    "Action video game experience results in more efficient use of sensory evidence. Importantly, these improvements are not restricted to the visual modality, but appear in the auditory modality as well. Moreover, 50 hr of action video game training led to qualitatively similar results in a group of NVGPs [Non Video-Game Players], establishing a causative relationship between action video game experience and improved probabilistic inference."

    All this means that video game playing results in a more efficient use of auditory and visual evidence leading to faster and better decision making. Up until now, research into video game effects has only demonstrated that playing video games makes you better at playing video games. Not quite the industrial application that businesses and the military are looking for here. Yet the research paper, imposingly titled, "Improved Probabilistic Inference as a General Learning Mechanism with Action Video Games" concludes that
    "improvements after action game training are not limited to playing the game itself, but generalize to new tasks. Gamers, we propose, acquire the ability to dynamically retune the connectivity between the momentary evidence layer and the layer integrating the evidence based on the statistics of the very task they are performing."

    The new skills we learn while playing video games are transferable to other activities. The Economist suggests that the implications of this research will be found in improved reaction times within the population (after all, 67% of American households include at least one video-gamer). Furthermore, "if video-gamers are really better equipped to make quick decisions, they might also turn out to be better drivers and end up in fewer accidents."

    Forty thousand people died on America`s highways last year. I bet that over the past thirty years of growth in video-gaming, the death rate on America`s highways has seen no significant decrease.

    Video-gaming may make for faster decisions, but speed was at the very heart of the problem of the housing crisis and the stock market -- very smart people very quickly making very foolish decisions.

    Increased speed and efficiency in decision making does not and will not lead to wiser decisions. We have had over twenty years of "improved" networked collective intelligence, yet our major problems remain unsolved and are growing in consequence and severity.

    Gaming will not make us smarter, anymore than the Internet will make us wiser. There is more at work when we make decisions than just speed.

    Being fast at fragging is not an item for your resume. At least, not until further research . . .

    Dr. Strangelove (a.k.a. [TG] E-Male)
    Author of The Empire of Mind: Digital Piracy and the Anti-capitalist Movement, and
    Watching YouTube: Extraordinary Videos by Ordinary People, (University of Toronto Press).

    • Grunt 70
      Grunt 70 commented
      Editing a comment
      1000 Points off the bat for not saying the m _ _ _ _ _ is the m_ _ _ _ _ _ .

      At any rate I'm enjoying your observations about how gaming influences culture and vice versa.

    • Warlab
      Warlab commented
      Editing a comment
      Re: Not as Smart as We Think We Are

      Originally posted by E-Male
      Yet there is, as yet, no research that demonstrates that as a group, gamers are better employees.

      From what I know of 70 years of research into media effects -- don't hold your breath. It is highly unlikely that gaming makes us better at decision-making in life, or smarter, than the average population.
      Given that the study showed that gamers made decisions just a correctly as non-gamers, I'd say faster decision making is a personal asset. One that makes their decision making process better.

    • Jackspyder
      Jackspyder commented
      Editing a comment
      another interesting read there E-Mail. also is it strange i watch your lectures on YT even though im half way round the world studying a different course?
    Posting comments is disabled.

Latest Articles


  • Elite: Dangerous: 2.4 The Return AND BEYOND
    Elite: Dangerous: 2.4 The Return AND BEYOND

    by ScratchnSniff0

    Greetings Commanders!

    Today Frontier Developmentsb(here on referred to as FDEV) hosted the Frontier Expo 17, during which the relayed a lot of juicy news related to all their games that they are working on, including what is going on this year with ‘Elite: Dangerous.’


    FDEV called the last season of updates ‘Horizons,’ and they are calling this new year of updates...
    10-12-2017, 12:59 PM
  • Elite: Dangerous: Horizons Commanders Update
    Greeting Commanders!

    Today, Frontier Developments has released Elite Dangerous Horizons update 2.3...The Commander's Update! The update features the long awaited Commander Creator creation feature and the multi-crew mode! Change Log

    Commander Creator

    Commander Creator - PAX East 2017 - Elite Dangerous

    The Commander Creator is a sophisticated human modeler designed for the creation of an avatar with the player in mind. The modeler was created...
    04-11-2017, 12:54 PM
  • A big week for SQUAD
    Today marks the start of an action packed week for teamwork focused, tactical shooter Squad, the early access title from Offworld Industries.

    New Map released

    First up is the release of the much anticipated Al Basrah map. A remake of the hugely popular Project Reality original, Al Basrah heralds a new level of urban city combat with the Insurgent Faction facing off against the US Army.

    Early previews suggest savage house to house fighting with a heavy focus...
    04-05-2017, 11:27 AM
  • Elite Dangerous: Guardians
    Elite Dangerous is soon to experience a much anticipated update known as “Guardians.” It is expected to bring many new features and mechanics to the game as a whole. These features include NPC crews, small fighters, equippable hangers, and even a tourism industry.

    During Gamescom, Elite Dangerous fans were given much information relating to the upcoming Guardians update. As a person who has been watching the game change, it is definitely a lot to take in. For the sake of the reading audience, allow me to try to keep this...
    10-14-2016, 11:30 PM
  • TG is going to Tanoa - Apex of ArmA 3 begins July 11
    Apex DLC is Coming To TG Servers

    Get ready for the ride to the pinnacle of ArmA 3. Bohemia Interactive is releasing their latest achievement on July 11th featuring a Pacific jungle island Tanoa, a plethora of new features and a rich and long awaited set of assets in the ArmA tradition. will be hosting this content upon release. We will be churning out missions immediately!

    Tanoa alone is impressive, with 5 airports, its single main island, four minor islands and a bunch of “mini” islands it’s set to expand the ArmA empire to include much more land/sea battle capabilities and add elements of small island south pacific tropical exotic-ness to the ArmA franchise.

    Covering over 100 square Kilometers (about one third of the original ArmA Altis map) it is a tropical island paradise. Set in an idyllic setting it’s not militarized like Stratis, Altis or many other maps and this one is truly a clear slate for scenarios. With that said it’s not without its history, exploited for its rich mining productivity the island has been industrialized and ravaged for what looks like decades. There is a new faction, "The Syndikat", a local criminal organization with deep roots on Tanoa. This initial primary faction is made up of armed thugs and ex-paramilitaries, and is involved in many illicit operations throughout the region. Armed with mostly ‘classic’ weaponry such as AKs, RPGs, and 9 mm pistols their knowledge of the island and local hiding spots will make them a formidable enemy when the DLC is released.
    07-11-2016, 05:00 AM
  • Exciting CitizenCon Reveals and How Trolls Helped Push the Community Over 1M Backers

    Some People Live Under Bridges

    There has long been a small but ongoing undercurrent of Star Citizen criticism in some corners of the internet, mostly consisting of (IMO, baseless) accusations of "vaporware", "scam", etc. Apparently, in at least one case (Derek Smart) they have gotten so bad recently that Chris Roberts felt the need to publicly reply. Prior to this, I had never even heard of Derek Smart, but it didn't take me much research to find out that the guy is basically a professional troll. Apparently, once upon a time he had developed a couple games, that many people panned as unfinished and pretty bad in general. So, unable to achieve success on his own, he has apparently turned to latching onto more successful projects in a sad attempt at keeping his own name relevant. And seeing as how I had never heard of him prior to this drama, I suppose successful troll is successful. Although I really can't get my head around why anyone would set out to make that sort of name for themselves.
    10-19-2015, 05:41 AM