No announcement yet.

Free Speech and Video Games


  • Free Speech and Video Games

    Video games are more than just a product of the entertainment industry. They are artistic, political, and religious expressions. For anyone remotely familiar with the medium, this claim is obvious and needs no defense. Whether it is BioShock, the Sims, Farmville, or Castle Wolfenstein, all video games function not merely as an art form, but they are also vehicles for expression. Fans, artists, and scholars alike have used the medium of video games to create commentaries on many aspect of contemporary life.

    I have been playing my way through BioShock: Welcome to Rapture (2008) and enjoying the backdrop of Glided Age architecture, art deco inconography, and the Andrews Sisters in the sound track. Bioshock provides a ironic commentary on libertanianism, Christian fundamentalism, the Enlightenment, and free market economics. It is widely seen as one of the first times a major philosopher (Ayn Rand) was used as an inspiration for a game's storyline and zeitgeist.

    BioShock is a fable about the failure of a pro-capitalist philosophy that elevates man over god, the environment, and eventually, man over man. It also involves shooting a mother caring for a (dead) child, and countless other acts of virtual violence that is found in popular first person shooters. BioShock is not a "beat hookers to death with baseball bat" kind of game, but it is certainly mature content.

    America's Supreme Court is about to deliver a decision that will either acknowledge the artistic nature of video games or begin a new era of the moralistic repression of art and expression in the United States. Oddly enough, the very country that has been at the forefront of advances in rights for women, blacks, and gays is also one that appears to be constantly on the edge of a return to the darkness of McCarthyism and made-in-America dystopia.

    It is doubly ironic that the Supreme Court is faced with deciding the merits of video games as an artistic medium when we find games such as BioShock that act as commentaries on the dangers of economic and religious fascism.

    However the Supreme Court decides to treat video games under First Amendment doctrine, it is unlikely that "a law banning violent games would be good policy even if it passed constitutional muster," as was suggested in the New York Times. Unfortunately, both lawyers and judges have demonstrated considerable ignorance concerning the artistic merits of even the most violent video games and tend to have a naive understanding of the very limited effects of media violence on the young.

    When Joseph Nye was Dean of the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University he made the argument that, for more peace and prosperity for all, the world needs more McDonald's and Disney. Nye's "soft power" thesis proposed that the world would be a better place if America's values spread to the rest of the world. These American values, symbolized by Ronald McDonald and Mickey Mouse -- fast food, free markets, and corporate entertainment products -- would spread through a globalized free market and conquer the world on behalf of an Empire that is finding the "hard power" of its military to be ever more expensive and ineffective.

    Nye's thesis was welcomed by neoconservatives and ridiculed by those with a more nuanced understanding of the post-colonial world system. Nonetheless, intellectuals on both the left and the right recognize that the entertainment system is a significant form of power. Censoring video games, treating them under the law as merely consumer goods, would remove a powerful tool from America's arsenal of cultural weapons. Worse yet, a wrong approach to video games by the Supreme Court would reduce America's ability to understand the internal threats it faces from the more caustic aspects of unrestrained corporate power and rampant individualism.

    The world may not need more junk food and ideological amusement parks, but America does need more BioShock.

    And now, a bit of video-game artistic expression . . .
    Best viewed in 1080p HD.

    And here is a great backgrounder on the current video game case before the Supreme Court.

    • BigGaayAl
      BigGaayAl commented
      Editing a comment
      A detail perhaps, but this:

      "Oddly enough, the very country that has been at the forefront of advances in rights for women, blacks, and gays"

      seems to be rather Americo-centric.
      I mean gay rights in the US are still abysmal, abortion doctors are being shot which is related to women's rights, and all black people seem to be in jail.

      It is but a detail though, but rly the US isn't at all at the forefront here. Rather I see a tenuous balance with some advances, but equally strong tendencies to go back to the 'traditional family values' and all that jazz.

      Only in the area of freedom of speech, I see the US as a frontrunner. If only because AFAIK you are allowed to swear at a cop, which will get you arrested or fined in most countries like mine.

    • E-Male
      E-Male commented
      Editing a comment
      Good Point, BigGaayAl, but you read too much into my comment. The U.S. is clearly conflicted over basic human rights, such as gay marriage. But my point was not about their current cultural war.

      I think the U.S. plays a role in establishing gay rights (for example). Clearly it would be wrong to claim that they lead they way always in all rights, but when they are not busy persecuting their own citizens for being communist (or socialist, or liberal) they did bring some good ideas to the table.

      Dr. Strangelove (E-Male)

    • L3TUC3
      L3TUC3 commented
      Editing a comment
      Re: Free Speech and Video Games

      Originally posted by Eroak
      Adult content has been restricted for some time now in the form of paper and video. The internet has "bypassed" many of these restrictions but most hold a 18 year old boundary to buying adult form of entertainment which many consider a form of cencored art.

      I'm not against the ban of any form of media but I do understand some "restrictions" can help. I wouldn't want my 10 year old going and buying a violent game or movie. My kid isn't able to comprehend many of the actions and their meaning yet. Although this would be hard for her to do and I keep involved with her content inside my home, but kids are sneaky and smart and find ways. That could give me another layer of protection. But on the other hand, I feel that 18 is to restrictive. Buy this time many kids are able to discern the actions depicted in this media.

      The other hand of the argument is parents should be able to self moderate this in itself. In my honest opinion, I lack faith in the american parent in knowing whats best for their kids. I seen to much neglect, theres over 6000 open cases in Bucks County alone and this is as rich suburban upper middle class as you can get.

      Bans, no. Censoring, nah. Buying restrictions, some maybe.
      Bans and restrictions will cause self-censorship as publishers will aim for the lowest common denominator that's allowed to be sold in most major retail-outlets (while games remain an impulse buy and). It's rather old bag really, as this is already applied in the case of wal-mart, which does not carry ao games. One can imagine that developers will strip out some features to cajole the esrb into a M or T rating. Then there's the chains that voluntarily ID the buyer based on the rating. This is a great tool for parents, but no sure-fire way against it.

      In any case, the kids interests in video games will remain as it is, with the forbidden fruit as the ultimate goal. Oddly enough, for the majority of skewed rating game sales (I was going to write under-age, but there's no such thing as of yet), it's the parents who were responsible for the buy in question. One could ponder the reasons for this.

      1. Ignorance (parent unaware of rating or simply getting what the kid wants)
      2. Intention (parent aware of rating and deems kid mature enough)

      As more and more adolescents of the gamer generation grow into adulthood and have children of their own, I'm convinced that parents (like Eroak) will approach the medium with the proper caution and knowledge how to bring it to their offspring. Just like their great great grandparents did with dime-novels, great grandparents did with music, grandparents did with movies and parents with TV. I too find the neglect cases worrisome, and blaming the problems kids face today on video games is rather saddening (not to mention not proven).

      From a technological standpoint, I believe the problem of skewed game sales will diminish over time, as sales tend to go towards digital distribution. Then it's as simple for the parents as blocking the store with a password/age lock/credit-card and your kid can remain blissfully unaware of the dangers that lurk. Just like you can do already with most modern consoles.

      Parental controls ftw.

      Also, nice article Dr. Strangelove. However, I do not think that an age restriction will hamper games from being used as an experimental vessel for artistic expression, but rather become a hurdle for mass-consumption and sale for Big Games (EA/Activision/Ubisoft). An ideological message can as easily be conveyed with imagery that does not require any nudity or depraved scenes. If an artist does wish to go beyond, he's still free to do so, he just won't make as much money of his creation when it happens to be popular. True artists are poor for a reason =)

      If you like BioShock, you should try playing Deus Ex sometime. It's filled to the brim with theology, mythology, and conspiracy. Also Fallout 3 has some interesting what-if scenarios.
    Posting comments is disabled.

Latest Articles


  • TG is going to Tanoa - Apex of ArmA 3 begins July 11
    Apex DLC is Coming To TG Servers

    Get ready for the ride to the pinnacle of ArmA 3. Bohemia Interactive is releasing their latest achievement on July 11th featuring a Pacific jungle island Tanoa, a plethora of new features and a rich and long awaited set of assets in the ArmA tradition. will be hosting this content upon release. We will be churning out missions immediately!

    Tanoa alone is impressive, with 5 airports, its single main island, four minor islands and a bunch of ďminiĒ islands itís set to expand the ArmA empire to include much more land/sea battle capabilities and add elements of small island south pacific tropical exotic-ness to the ArmA franchise.

    Covering over 100 square Kilometers (about one third of the original ArmA Altis map) it is a tropical island paradise. Set in an idyllic setting itís not militarized like Stratis, Altis or many other maps and this one is truly a clear slate for scenarios. With that said itís not without its history, exploited for its rich mining productivity the island has been industrialized and ravaged for what looks like decades. There is a new faction, "The Syndikat", a local criminal organization with deep roots on Tanoa. This initial primary faction is made up of armed thugs and ex-paramilitaries, and is involved in many illicit operations throughout the region. Armed with mostly Ďclassicí weaponry such as AKs, RPGs, and 9 mm pistols their knowledge of the island and local hiding spots will make them a formidable enemy when the DLC is released.
    07-11-2016, 06:00 AM
  • Exciting CitizenCon Reveals and How Trolls Helped Push the Community Over 1M Backers

    Some People Live Under Bridges

    There has long been a small but ongoing undercurrent of Star Citizen criticism in some corners of the internet, mostly consisting of (IMO, baseless) accusations of "vaporware", "scam", etc. Apparently, in at least one case (Derek Smart) they have gotten so bad recently that Chris Roberts felt the need to publicly reply. Prior to this, I had never even heard of Derek Smart, but it didn't take me much research to find out that the guy is basically a professional troll. Apparently, once upon a time he had developed a couple games, that many people panned as unfinished and pretty bad in general. So, unable to achieve success on his own, he has apparently turned to latching onto more successful projects in a sad attempt at keeping his own name relevant. And seeing as how I had never heard of him prior to this drama, I suppose successful troll is successful. Although I really can't get my head around why anyone would set out to make that sort of name for themselves.
    10-19-2015, 06:41 AM
  • Elite: Dangerous - Horizons

    Frontier Developments released Elite: Dangerous last year and is now getting ready to release a new season of updates entitled Horizons. Thatís right, I said season, not expansion. Frontier has been releasing new features and updates to the game on a periodic basis over a long window of time that they refer to as a "season". The base game released as a single season and we saw a few new features, ships, and other items added to the game.

    If you have been paying attention to the game, you might have seen that some of these updates included the ability to form wings with other players (Wings Update), the ability to pledge with and support a minor power (Powerplay Update), the upcoming area combat (CQC Update), and eventually the Ships update which will bring the current total number of ships up to 30; or 31 depending on if you have Horizons coming to you in some fashion. This will bring Season One (or up to patch 1.5) to an end. Donít worry if you did not buy Horizons, they will still patch and update the base game and you will still be able to play. You will just not get to enjoy some of the newer features that this new season will bring.
    10-15-2015, 10:37 AM
  • ArmA Insurgency New Life and New Blood on Altis
    "Pandora: The Insurgency" Unique version hosted at TG

    Keen on tactics and strong team based play? Stop by TacticalGamer.comís Insurgency server for ArmA 3 and join the team as we take on the insurgents on Altis. Itís a 24/7 job. No MODs and no requirements to get in on some amazing ArmA 3 action. Join us today!!

    Built on a persistent framework it calls troops to join in the fight to clear the island of Altis of a scourge of insurgents. These arenít your average insurgents; they possess skills and weaponry that keeps the best squads on their toes. Their flanking tactics and relentless aggression are legendary. Anti-armor capabilities that keep the armor in the rear and, squads need to take special note that ďnoiseĒ in a region with other enemy cells nearby may cause those cells to activate and respond to the threat. So small cells that seem ďeasyĒ to clear suddenly become beehives of insurgents attacking and flanking a small expeditionary force....
    09-24-2015, 02:47 PM
  • Project Reality Server is Back!
    As some of you saw today, the PR server is back online!

    We will be running the server on a part-time basis, most likely 3 days/nights a week, possibly 4. It is our opinion that this will work best in lieu of running the server 24/7 and having it sit empty most of the day. Additionally, the last time we tried to re-boot the server, we had big issues with getting people to help the seed the server. It is our hope that with a schedule that is known for the week, everyone will look forward to the days that server is up (much like we all looked forward to Thursday password nights) and the server will be full very quickly.

    So, what's the schedule? Great question! We don't know yet. The admin team will make a post later this week with specific dates and times, but the weekend is a pretty safe bet for right now.

    In the meantime, if you have any questions or suggestions, please get a hold of the admin team in the Contact An Admin forum.

    Look forward to seeing everyone on the battlefield!
    07-20-2015, 09:39 AM
  • TacticalGamer / Squad Kickstarter Promotional Offer
    Tactical Gamer is pleased to announce that we are offering a special offer for our members on the upcoming first-person tactical shooter, Squad. Squad is an online multiplayer first-person shooter that aims to capture combat realism through communication and team play. Large open maps combined with strong squad cohesion mechanics, vehicles and player-constructed bases create a heart-thumping, visceral gaming experience which mixes organized tactical multi-squad planning with split second decision-making in real world scale firefights, with up to 50 players per side.
    05-29-2015, 04:11 PM